A judge has dismissed charges against all the defendants in a trial related to an Oireachtas Golf Society event.
Galway East Independent TD Noel Grealish, 55, former Fianna Fail senator Donie Cassidy, 75, John Sweeney, 60, and his son James Sweeney, 32, who own the Station House Hotel, had been accused of illegally holding the event in August 2020.
All four faced a single charge that they organised an event that contravened the Health Act 1947, as amended, to prevent, limit, minimise or slow the spread of Covid-19.
The alleged offence related to a dinner at the Station House Hotel in Clifden, Co Galway, which was attended by 81 people.
Dismissing the charges first against Mr Grealish, and then against the other three accused, Judge Mary Fahy told the court that the evidence had been “impressive”.
“I have no doubt that the organisers, in conjunction with proprietors, did everything they could to comply. In my view, they did comply. Not in the court of public opinion, but in the court of law.
“Unfortunately, as a result of this dinner, very good people lost very good positions and contracts. But I want to make it clear I didn’t make my decision based on that.”
Former Fianna Fáil minister Dara Calleary had appeared briefly as a witness in the trial on Thursday. The Fianna Fail TD resigned as Agriculture Minister in the wake of the controversy, after attending the event.
“It was very clear that every precaution was being taken in terms of Covid-19 guidelines,” he told the court.
He said that Mr John Sweeney had been greeting guests as they arrived, “which was reassuring”. He said that he checked into the hotel and at the function, he was at a table of six in the corner of the room.
Covid protocols
He said that staff went through the Covid-19 protocols at the table. “It wasn’t a normal function”, he said, describing the space between tables.
He said he was “very conscious, in the room we were in, everything was very much compliant”. Mr Calleary said that he estimated 45-46 people were in the room.
He recalled seeing “another space, on the far side of the partition” while he gave a speech. Asked by the prosecution how wide the partition was, he said it was “my width”.
He also said that the divide, or partition, “succeeded” in preventing mingling.
Later, Garda John O’Donovan, appearing as a someone who had attended the event, said that the gap was “slightly larger than a door”.
He told defence counsel that he felt “safe” at the event. In the course of questioning, he also said: “I thought everybody was trying to do their best.”
Earlier, a garda had rejected any suggestion that he leaked information to the media that two politicians were to be charged with breaching coronavirus regulations at a controversial golf society dinner.
Inspector Peter Conlon, who led the investigation, was accused by Mr Colm Smyth, representing Mr Cassidy, of leaking details to Irish Independent journalists regarding a story on February 17th, 2021 that the defendants were set to be prosecuted in relation to the event.
Mr Smyth said that his had happened before the defendants had been formally notified themselves.
Mr Conlon rejected the allegation in the strongest terms.
He also said that he was not aware of the Irish Independent article.
Mr Conlon said that all four men had been contacted by phone at the exactly the same time regarding the fact they were to be prosecuted He said that call was made on either February 16th or February 17th, 2021.
Taking questions later from Defence Counsel Michael McDowell, who represented Mr Grealish, it was put to Mr Conlon that the present court case would not have happened had the event been organised in “two different rooms and with a partition”.
“The air was circulating from one room to another, so it would be my assertion that yes it was one room,” Mr Conlon had said during questions from Mr McDowell.
Mr McDowell had said that his client was not an organiser of the event.
At the outset of proceedings on Thursday, the Director of Public Prosecutions was accused by defence counsel Eddie Walsh, representing John Sweeney, of acting like a “separate state”, in a back-and-forth between the prosecution and defence over the acceptance of Government Covid-19 guidelines as formal evidence by the court.
Eoghan Cole, the prosecution counsel, had said that he would accept the use of the Fáilte Ireland Covid-19 guidelines as a defence exhibit.
Mr Walsh said that the attitude of the prosecution towards the guidelines is “devoid of reality”.
CCTV
“For the DPP to seek to ignore the Government of Ireland is outrageous. Is the DPP a separate state? Is the DPP ignoring the Government of Ireland?”
The prosecution robustly rejected that accusations in court on Thursday and said that the DPP was independent of the Government.
It also transpired during the course of proceedings that no CCTV was provided to gardai investigating the incident.
There was, the court heard, no legal basis for Irish police to be provided with the CCTV footage in this case.
The court also heard that there was no CCTV of the function room in question.
