Windsor Framework: Stormont to vote on extending post-Brexit trading deal

ireland
Windsor Framework: Stormont To Vote On Extending Post-Brexit Trading Deal
The democratic consent exercise is required as part of the UK and EU’s Windsor Framework agreement. Photo: PA
Share this article

By David Young, PA

Stormont Assembly members will vote later on whether to continue with the North’s post-Brexit trading arrangements.

The previously stated voting intentions of the main parties suggest that members will back the extension of the measures for another four years when they convene on Tuesday.

Advertisement

The democratic consent process is a key element of the UK and EU’s Windsor Framework deal and is designed to give local elected representatives a say on the contentious trade rules that now operate in the region.

The debate and vote will happen a day after a judge dismissed an emergency legal action by a loyalist activist who had challenged the lawfulness of triggering of the vote.

General Election Ireland 2024
Northern Secretary Hilary Benn initiated the process required to hold the vote. Photo: PA

Advertisement

The framework, and its predecessor the NI Protocol, require checks and customs paperwork on goods moving from Britain into Northern Ireland.

Under the arrangements, which were designed to ensure no hardening of the land border post-Brexit, Northern Ireland continues to follow many EU trade and customs rules.

This has proved highly controversial, with unionists arguing the system threatens the North’s place in the United Kingdom.

Advocates of the arrangements say they help insulate the region from negative economic consequences of Brexit.

Advertisement

A dispute over the so-called Irish Sea border led to the collapse of the Northern Ireland Assembly in 2022, when the DUP withdrew then-first minister Paul Givan from the coalition executive.

The impasse lasted two years and ended in February when devolution returned.

Under the terms of the framework, a Stormont vote must be held on articles five to 10 of the Windsor Framework, which underpin the EU trade laws in force in Northern Ireland, before they expire.

The vote must take place before December 17th.

Advertisement

Based on the numbers in the Assembly, MLAs are set to back the continuation of the measures for another four years, even though unionists are likely to oppose the move.

DUP leader Gavin Robinson has already made clear his party will be voting against continuing the operation of the Windsor Framework.

MLAs from Sinn Féin, the SDLP and Alliance Party, which all favour continuation, submitted the required motion to table the vote after Stormont’s first and deputy first ministers failed to reach an agreement to do it jointly themselves.

The process to trigger the vote began at the end of October when Northern Secretary Hilary Benn sent a letter to the Speaker Edwin Poots asking First Minister Michelle O’Neill and deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly to table a motion by the end of November.

Advertisement

Given the DUP is opposed to a continuation of arrangements that have brought added red tape on trade with the rest of the UK, it was not expected that a motion calling for their extension would be forthcoming from the joint office of a Sinn Fein First Minister and a DUP deputy First Minister.

Once the one-month time period for Ms O’Neill and Ms Little-Pengelly to table the motion expired at the end of November, it was open for other MLAs in Stormont to do it – prompting Sinn Féin’s Philip McGuigan, the Alliance Party’s Eoin Tennyson and the SDLP’s Matthew O’Toole to table it together.

Unlike other votes on contentious issues at Stormont, the motion does not require cross-community support to pass.

Brexit
Jamie Bryson failed to secure leave for a judicial review into the democratic consent process after a late night court ruling on Monday (David Young/PA).

If it is voted through with a simple majority, the arrangements are extended for four years.

In that event, the British government is obliged to hold an independent review of how the framework is working.

If it wins cross-community support, which is a majority of unionists and a majority of nationalists, then it is extended for eight years.

The chances of it securing such cross-community backing are highly unlikely.

On Monday night, Belfast High Court judge Mr Justice McAlinden rejected loyalist activist Jamie Bryson’s application for leave for a full judicial review hearing against Mr Benn’s move to trigger the vote.

Mr Bryson had initially asked the court to grant interim relief in his challenge to prevent Tuesday’s vote taking place, pending the hearing of a full judicial review.

Ireland
Legal bid initiated to stop Stormont vote on North...
Read More

However, he abandoned that element of his leave application during proceedings on Monday, after the judge made clear he would be “very reluctant” to do anything that would be “trespassing into the realms” of a democratically elected Assembly.

Mr Bryson had challenged Mr Benn’s move to initiate the democratic consent process but all three grounds of his application for leave were dismissed.

After the ruling, Mr Bryson told the court he intended to appeal to the Belfast Court of Appeal.

Read More

Advertisement

Most read