A woman who assaulted a homeless man because she wrongly believed he had raped her sister may be asked to carry out community service in lieu of a prison sentence.
Zara McCabe (34) of Brookview Drive, Tallaght, Dublin 24, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to assault causing harm on Fleet Street, Dublin 2 on November 4th, 2020. She has 21 previous convictions including assault, threats, intoxication in a public place and road traffic offences.
The court heard that there was no medical report in relation to the victim, as, although he was taken to hospital by ambulance, he didn’t sign a consent form to release his medical report and discharged himself the following day. The victim died by suicide a week later.
It was accepted that McCabe, a mother of five, was highly intoxicated and in poor mental health on the night and wrongly believed that the man had raped her sister.
McCabe later said that she went through the victim’s pockets after the assault because she was trying to find his phone to take a photo of him to show her sister.
Community service
Judge Martin Nolan adjourned the case to allow for McCabe to be assessed by the Probation Service to determine if she is suitable for community service. He said if found suitable he would order that she carry out 150 hours community service in lieu of a two-year prison term.
“You are getting a considerable chance,” Judge Nolan told McCabe.
“What you did on the night was disgraceful to this poor man. If you re-offend you will go to jail, simple as that. It was totally wrong. He had a tough enough life without you attacking him,” the judge said.
Judge Nolan said it was not clear what injuries the man sustained, but it seems he had cuts to his body.
“He was taken to hospital and didn’t stay long. This poor man had an unfortunate life and an unfortunate end,” the judge said.
He said McCabe had wrongly thought this man had raped her sister which he said was “more based on her condition than the objective facts of the situation”, before he acknowledged that she was drunk and had probably taken drugs.
He acknowledged that she had a record of conviction and long-standing alcohol and addictive problems. He said McCabe had a “very unfortunate family life” before he noted that her children are in care, and she has been subjected to other forms of abuse over the years.
Judge Nolan acknowledged that McCabe is “on an upward curve at the moment” and has secured work in a warehouse since last November before he remanded her on continuing bail, pending the report from the Probation Service, to June 27th next.
Garda Jordan Kennedy told Fiona Crawford BL, prosecuting, that gardaí were called to the scene after a support worker for the housing facility the victim was staying in in Temple Bar, saw that he was being assaulted by McCabe and two men.
Witnesses later told gardaí that they could see the woman sticking something into the victim and “a fella kicking him in the head”. The group were described as violent and the woman as “the main aggressor”.
Gda Kennedy said when officers arrived the two men walked away, but the woman went through the victim’s pockets and continually called him a rapist. It was noted that the victim was bloody and disorientated.
McCabe was arrested and told gardaí that she had kicked the man to death. “I had a blade. I would have killed him. He is a rapist. He raped my sister. These two lads helped me.”
CCTV
Gda Kennedy said gardaí secured CCTV footage that captured the assault and confirmed that it lasted 30 minutes.
He said that in interview McCabe told gardaí that she hoped she had killed the man.
Gda Kennedy agreed with Aoife O’Leary BL, defending, that her client was homeless at the time and was highly intoxicated on the night. She was not wearing any shoes.
He accepted that although witnesses say they saw McCabe sticking something into the victim, none of his injuries were consistent with such an attack. His injuries, though they could not be confirmed by way of a medical report, included bruises and scrapes.
Gda Kennedy agreed that McCabe was remorseful when she was shown the CCTV footage, but continued to maintain that she attacked him for a reason.
She described herself as “horrible, disgusting, a scumbag and a failure” during garda interview and Gda Kennedy accepted that her mental health was very poor at the time.
If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article, you can freephone the Samaritans 24 hours a day for confidential support at 116 123 or email jo@samaritans.org.
You can also freephone the national Bereavement Support Line run by the HSE and Irish Hospice Foundation at 1800 80 70 77 (Monday-Friday 10am-1pm), and the contact information for a range of mental health supports is available at mentalhealthireland.ie/get-support/.
In the case of an emergency, or if you or someone you know is at risk of suicide or self-harm, dial 999/112.
